Tuesday, July 30, 2013

Topic 3 - Hitler Opposition Notes


~ Hitler Policy Notes ~

General Opposition:
o      Recently, much more attention focused on opposition by historians
o      Grumbling to general political activism to threatening resistance
o      Dissent about lack of wage increases, increased working hours, compulsory activities, and the subordination of consumer interests to rearmament
o      Discontent was low compared to resistance of peasantry in Soviet Union
o      Grumbling sparked by economic conditions, not fundamental reservations
o      Preferred Hitler to the Weimar Republic

Youth Opposition:
o      Growth of social deviance that threatened to undermine re-education of youth
o      Edelweiss Pirates – antagonist to authority and Hitler Youth, whose patrols they would ambush and beat up
o      Slogan was ‘Eternal War on the Hitler Youth’
o      Supported the Allies during war and offered help to German army deserters
o      Swing movement was provocative and as jazz was ‘negro music’ it was degenerate
o      Lacked the organizational edge to be anything more than an embarrassment to the regime
o      Social deviance was never a serious opposition

Church Opposition:
o      Catholics protested to replacing crucifixes with portraits of Hitler in Catholic schools
o      Opposition to regime’s euthanasia program from 1939
o      Nazify schools and euthanasia were temporarily suspended
o      Protestant opposition less likely to succeed than Catholic, due to fragmentation and division
o      Catholic church was centralized with considerable capacity for exerting pressure

Party Opposition:
o      Communists and Social Democrats
o      Failed badly
o      SPD voted against Enabling Act, so funds seized and exiled
o      Underground members produced rebellious propaganda
o      Gestapo had success in identifying and eradicating opposers
o      KPD activities were banned after Reich fire
o      Produced over 1 million anti-Nazi leaflets between 1933 and 35
o      10% of whole Communist membership were killed
o      Thälmann, the leader of the KPD was arrested in 1933
o      Communists impeded by external constraints such as the foreign policy of Stalin and the Nazi-Soviet Non-Aggression Pact
o      Not until 1941, when Hitler invaded the USSR that Communists retorted
o      Strongest form of resistance was the attempt to remove the regime all together
o      Only done by a coup as all the constitutional channels had been blocked by Hitler’s ‘legal revolution’
o      Reason for the failure of an armed resistance – there was simply no depth in numbers to offset the failure of individual attempts like the Stauffenburg bomb plot
o      General Beck tried to persuade the General Staff to remove Hitler in 1938, and also urged the British government to resist Hitler’s demands for the Sudetenland
o      Rommel participated in a plot against Hitler’s life
o      Conservatives wanted to replace Hitler’s regime with a more democratic one to negociate an armistice with Allies
o      Would be no November 1918, since Hitler was head of state and not open to any attempt to deal
o      Allies insisted on an unconditional surrender thereby removing an important component from the campaign of the resistance movement

Prevention Opposition:
o      Enabling Act
o      Law against the formation of political parties (single party state)
o      Totalitarian state that eradicated institutions with formal expressions of dissent and opposition
o      Propaganda
o      Nazism could be removed only by conquering armies, not by internal revolution
o      Banned Jazz, left-wing art and literature, and modern art
o      Public hanging of Edelweiss Pirates
o      SS and SA to pick off individual manifestos and anti-Nazi behavior
o      Concentration camps
o      Gestapo
o      Opposition did develop in such a variety of forms indicating the totalitarianism was only partly successful
o      Volksgemeinschaft was not achieved
o      SPD fell from 14,000 in 1935 to 3800 in 1938 due to Gestapo arrests
o      1942 and 1944 Gestapo goes through with a relentless crackdown of Communist rebels and cripples the organization
o      The basic Gestapo law passed by the government in 1936 gave the Gestapo carte blanche to operate without judicial oversight. The Gestapo was specifically exempted from responsibility to administrative courts, where citizens normally could sue the state to conform to laws.
o      A further law passed later in the year gave the Gestapo responsibility for setting up and administering concentration camps.
o      Gestapo woke up people in the middle of the night and put them in court . Made citizens sign a paper pleading guilty often by torture
o      Gestapo was limited in numbers and depended on denunciations rather than spying directly on people.


Establishment:
o      Opposition of KPD
o      Youth
o      Church
o      Methods to deal – Gestapo
o      Not many people

Topic 3 - Hitler Notes


Historiography

Main Arguments:
A.J.P Taylor
·       Germany didn’t take signing seriously
·       Germans intended to repudiate it at some time, if it did not fall to pieces on its own absurdity
David Thompson
·       Allies could do no more than try to produce some order from chaos, determine the details of frontiers, and plan projects of compensation, and leave the achievement of greater precision and perfection to subsequent negotiation
·       Biggest mistake was to mention at all the ideals of absolute justice or perpetual peace – impossible outcome
Fritz Fischer
·       Germany between 1914 and 1918 tried to secure a position in the world which she believed was hers by right
·       This idea did not disappear with the fall of the monarch in 1918
John Terrain
·       War guilt clause was a stigma on the entire German nation
·       They resented it
G. Schultz
·       War ended with the collapse of the strongest military powers in Europe
·       Allies were therefore objectively free to decide their policies without limiting factors
·       Peacemakers failed to establish a permanent order
John Sherer
·       German sovereignty survived
·       Treaty restrictions were irksome, but made no serious inroads on national sovereignty
·       Made German nationalism
·       Created Hitler
·       Weakened but no so weakened that it could not rise again within a generation to threaten the balance of world power
Douglas Newton
·       Whether Germany was treated justly is not a question of fact but of moral judgment
·       Hash, but victorious Germany would have been harsh too
·       Peace fell short of the ideals of reconciliation

Quoted Evidence that suggests the Treaty was harsh to Germany:
·       A.J.P Taylor - “The treaty seemed to them wicked, unfair, dictation, slave treaty.’
·       Douglas Newton – “Peace which fell short of ideals of reconciliation”
Quoted Evidence that suggests the Treaty was fair to Germany:
·       John Sherer – “German Empire survived…it’s sovereignty was secure...alone of all the defeated nations it preserved its territorial unity.  The treaty restrictions were irksome, but made no serious inroads on national sovereignty.”  “Germany was weakened, but not so weakened it could that it could not rise.”

What historians claim the Treaty caused problems for the future? What were some of those problems?
·       APJ Taylor – “Germans intended to repudiate it at some time in the future.”
·       David Thompson - “The mentality [to secure a position in the world, which she believed was he right] did not disappear with the fall of the monarchy”
·       John Sherer – “Provided a powerful stimulus for German nationalism

To What extent does the Treaty of Versailles reflect that the Great War was not the war to end war?
·       John Sherer – “Germany was weakened, but not so weakened that it could not rise within a generation to threaten the balance of world power.”
·       Douglas Newton - “The absence of any genuine peace negotiations…made all of Germany believe the [Weimar] Republic had been treated shabbily. 

Prioritize each source in terms of usefulness and reliability to a historian studying the aftermath of the Great War:
·       Douglas Newton
·       John Sherer
·       AJP Taylor
·       G Shultz
·       Fritz Fisher
·       John Terrain

Weaknesses of the Weimar Republic:
Instability and server problems
·       Ineffective constitution
·       Left –wing rebellions
·       Right-wing terrorism
·       Inflations crisis of 1923


Failures of the Weimar Republic

Craig:
·       The Republic’s basic vulnerability was rooted in the circumstances of its creation

Geary:
·       The Weimar Republic failed to build on the fundamental compromises achieved in 1918; it had lost the hearts and the minds of the people

Ardagh
·       Germans were loosing faith in the very principle of parliamentary democracy…a growing number of politicians believed that democracy was unworkable

Hiden
·       No single problem ‘caused’ the downfall of the Weimar Republic…the interactions of…problems, many of which predated the Republic, progressively weakened the new German state.



Topic 1 - Historiography of Treaty of Versailles


Historiography

Main Arguments:
A.J.P Taylor
·       Germany didn’t take signing seriously
·       Germans intended to repudiate it at some time, if it did not fall to pieces on its own absurdity
David Thompson
·       Allies could do no more than try to produce some order from chaos, determine the details of frontiers, and plan projects of compensation, and leave the achievement of greater precision and perfection to subsequent negotiation
·       Biggest mistake was to mention at all the ideals of absolute justice or perpetual peace – impossible outcome
Fritz Fischer
·       Germany between 1914 and 1918 tried to secure a position in the world which she believed was hers by right
·       This idea did not disappear with the fall of the monarch in 1918
John Terrain
·       War guilt clause was a stigma on the entire German nation
·       They resented it
G. Schultz
·       War ended with the collapse of the strongest military powers in Europe
·       Allies were therefore objectively free to decide their policies without limiting factors
·       Peacemakers failed to establish a permanent order
John Sherer
·       German sovereignty survived
·       Treaty restrictions were irksome, but made no serious inroads on national sovereignty
·       Made German nationalism
·       Created Hitler
·       Weakened but no so weakened that it could not rise again within a generation to threaten the balance of world power
Douglas Newton
·       Whether Germany was treated justly is not a question of fact but of moral judgment
·       Hash, but victorious Germany would have been harsh too
·       Peace fell short of the ideals of reconciliation

Quoted Evidence that suggests the Treaty was harsh to Germany:
·       A.J.P Taylor - “The treaty seemed to them wicked, unfair, dictation, slave treaty.’
·       Douglas Newton – “Peace which fell short of ideals of reconciliation”
Quoted Evidence that suggests the Treaty was fair to Germany:
·       John Sherer – “German Empire survived…it’s sovereignty was secure...alone of all the defeated nations it preserved its territorial unity.  The treaty restrictions were irksome, but made no serious inroads on national sovereignty.”  “Germany was weakened, but not so weakened it could that it could not rise.”

What historians claim the Treaty caused problems for the future? What were some of those problems?
·       APJ Taylor – “Germans intended to repudiate it at some time in the future.”
·       David Thompson - “The mentality [to secure a position in the world, which she believed was he right] did not disappear with the fall of the monarchy”
·       John Sherer – “Provided a powerful stimulus for German nationalism

To What extent does the Treaty of Versailles reflect that the Great War was not the war to end war?
·       John Sherer – “Germany was weakened, but not so weakened that it could not rise within a generation to threaten the balance of world power.”
·       Douglas Newton - “The absence of any genuine peace negotiations…made all of Germany believe the [Weimar] Republic had been treated shabbily. 

Prioritize each source in terms of usefulness and reliability to a historian studying the aftermath of the Great War:
·       Douglas Newton
·       John Sherer
·       AJP Taylor
·       G Shultz
·       Fritz Fisher
·       John Terrain

Weaknesses of the Weimar Republic:
Instability and server problems
·       Ineffective constitution
·       Left –wing rebellions
·       Right-wing terrorism
·       Inflations crisis of 1923


Failures of the Weimar Republic

Craig:
·       The Republic’s basic vulnerability was rooted in the circumstances of its creation

Geary:
·       The Weimar Republic failed to build on the fundamental compromises achieved in 1918; it had lost the hearts and the minds of the people

Ardagh
·       Germans were loosing faith in the very principle of parliamentary democracy…a growing number of politicians believed that democracy was unworkable

Hiden
·       No single problem ‘caused’ the downfall of the Weimar Republic…the interactions of…problems, many of which predated the Republic, progressively weakened the new German state.



Topic 1 - Treaty of Versailles


~ Treaty of Versailles Notes ~

Verdicts on the Treaty:
·       The treaty angered Germany and did not even satisfy the Big Three
·       America (Woodrow Wilson)
o      Got a League of Nations
o      Self-determination for the peoples of Eastern Europe
o      Didn’t get all his ‘Fourteen Points’ in the treaty
o      When Wilson went back to America, the Senate refused to join the League of Nations and even refused to sign the Treaty of Versailles
·       England (Lloyd George)
o      Many people wanted to ‘make Germany pay’
o      Got some German colonies (expanded British Empire)
o      The small German navy helped Britain ‘rule the seas’
o      But, Lloyd George thought the treaty was too harsh and would ruin Germany
o      He thought it would cause another war in 25 years time
·       France (Georges Clemenceau)
o      Wanted revenge
o      Wanted reparations (would repair the damage to France)
o      Wanted a tiny army
o      Wanted demilitarized zone in Rhineland
o      Got Alsace Lorraine, and German colonies


 











Fourteen Points:
Woodrow Wilson's Fourteen Points were first outlined in a speech Wilson gave to the American Congress in January 1918. Wilson's Fourteen Points became the basis for a peace programme and it was on the back of the Fourteen Points that Germany and her allies agreed to an armistice in November 1918.
1. No more secret agreements ("Open covenants openly arrived at").
2. Free navigation of all seas.
3. An end to all economic barriers between countries.
4. Countries to reduce weapon numbers.
5. All decisions regarding the colonies should be impartial
6. The German Army is to be removed from Russia. Russia should be left to develop her own political set-up.
7. Belgium should be independent like before the war.
8. France should be fully liberated and allowed to recover Alsace-Lorraine
9. All Italians are to be allowed to live in Italy. Italy's borders are to "along clearly recognisable lines of nationality."
10. Self-determination should be allowed for all those living in Austria-Hungary.
11. Self-determination and guarantees of independence should be allowed for the Balkan states.
12. The Turkish people should be governed by the Turkish government. Non-Turks in the old Turkish Empire should govern themselves.
13. An independent Poland should be created which should have access to the sea.
14. A League of Nations should be set up to guarantee the political and territorial independence of all states. 

v    America did not sign Fourteen Points because
o      Didn’t join League of nations
o      Reparations
o      War guilt clause
o      African colonies
o      Congress and senate control/in charge of foreign policy
v    Fourteen Points was aimed to please general American public to convince them they had fought for something (democracy)
Territorial
v    The following land was taken away from Germany:
o      Alsace-Lorraine (given to France)
o      Eupen and Malmedy (given to Belgium)
o      Northern Schleswig (given to Denmark)
o      Hultschin (given to Czechoslovakia)
o      West Prussia, Posen and Upper Silesia (given to Poland)
v    The Saar, Danzig and Memel were put under the control of the League of Nations and the people of these regions would be allowed to vote to stay in Germany or not in a future referendum.
v    The League of Nations also took control of Germany's overseas colonies.
Germany had to return to Russia land taken in the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk. Some of this land was made into new states : Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia. An enlarged Poland also received some of this land.
Military
v    Germany’s army was reduced to 100,000 men; the army was not allowed tanks
v    She was not allowed an airforce She was allowed only 6 capital naval ships and no submarines The west of the Rhineland and 50 kms east of the River Rhine was made into a demilitarised zone (DMZ). No German soldier or weapon was allowed into this zone. The Allies were to keep an army of occupation on the west bank of the Rhine for 15 years.
Financial
v    The loss of vital industrial territory would be a severe blow to any attempts by Germany to rebuild her economy. Coal from the Saar and Upper Silesia in particular was a vital economic loss. Combined with the financial penalties linked to reparations, it seemed clear to Germany that the Allies wanted nothing else but to bankrupt her.
v    Germany was also forbidden to unite with Austria to form one superstate, in an attempt to keep her economic potential to a minimum.
v    General
v    There are three vital clauses here:
v    Germany had to admit full responsibility for starting the war. This was Clause 231 - the infamous "War Guilt Clause". 2. Germany, as she was responsible for starting the war as stated in clause 231, was, therefore responsible for all the war damage caused by the First World War. Therefore, she had to pay reparations, the bulk of which would go to France and Belgium to pay for the damage done to the infrastructure of both countries by the war. Quite literally, reparations would be used to pay for the damage to be repaired. Payment could be in kind or cash. The figure was not set at Versailles - it was to be determined later. The Germans were told to write a blank cheque which the Allies would cash when it suited them. The figure was eventually put at £6,600 million - a huge sum of money well beyond Germany’s ability to pay.
v    A League of Nations was set up to keep world peace. 
In fact, the first 26 clauses of the treaty dealt with the League's organisation.